Court Adjourns Ruling On Preliminary Objection In Ondo APC Chieftains' Suit To Jan 27


A defamation suit involving members of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in the same local government suffered a setback on Wednesday as the court adjourned to January 27, 2027, to rule on whether a preliminary objection filed by the defendants should be heard together with the substantive suit.

The suit has 35 defendants, with Barrister Adekola Olawoye as the first defendant. Counsel to the defendants, Shola Ajisafe, is representing 32 of the 35 defendants.

Speaking to journalists after proceedings, The Senior Advocate of Nigeria Olawoye said the case was slated for hearing of the defendants' preliminary objection, but the defence sought leave of the court to defer the hearing until the substantive suit is heard.

According to Olawoye, the move is to save judicial time.

 "This is to safeguard against the wastage of precious judicial time on the preliminary objection. It is an issue of jurisdiction, which can be raised at any stage of the trial, even for the first time at the Supreme Court," he said.

He explained that the preliminary objection is the defendants' position that the claimants' case is incompetent and discloses no reasonable cause of action.

 "We are saying that they do not have a case at all and that they have only come to court for a jamboree," Olawoye said.

Counsel to the defendants, Shola Adjisafe, corroborated the position, saying the objection was based on the totality of what the claimants brought before the court.

 "If the court says they have a case, we will proceed to trial. But if the court says they do not have a case, that will be the end of the matter," Ajisafe said.

Counsel to the claimants, Olaoluwa Imoru, however, vehemently opposed the application for deferment.

Imoru explained that a preliminary objection is a threshold issue that should be determined quickly before parties dissipate energy on trial.

 "If a preliminary objection is upheld, whatever proceedings have taken place could amount to an exercise in futility. That was our position. We believe it is better to address the issue now," he said.

He argued that the objection invites the court to delve into substantive issues at an interlocutory stage, particularly in a libel matter where issues of publication and defences should be determined during trial, not at the preliminary stage.

 "Even if we assume, without conceding, that a case is weak, the weakness of a case does not mean that it does not disclose a reasonable cause of action," Imoru added.

After listening to both parties, the court declined to give a bench ruling and adjourned to January 27, 2027, for a considered ruling on whether the preliminary objection should be taken together with the substantive case or heard immediately.

When asked if the intra-party court case could affect President Bola Tinubu's re-election bid in 2027, Olawoye dismissed the fear.

He said as elders and leaders of the APC in the local government, their primary objective is to ensure the President's re-election, targeting a minimum of one million votes, up from the 365,000 votes recorded in 2023.

 "Personally, we do not think this situation should negatively affect the coming election. The claimants cannot say they do not want President Tinubu to have a second term. It is only the unity of minds that is lacking, but the unity of purpose is there," he said.

He cited the Commissioner for Finance, who is the first claimant, saying he would not publicly declare that he does not want the President re-elected with massive votes.

On whether the opposition could capitalise on the disagreement, Olawoye said:

 "We don't have opposition. The party we used to have as opposition, the PDP, is in tatters now. There is no party rivaling the APC."

On out-of-court settlement, Olawoye said the elders remain open to reconciliation 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

"It is only the claimants who are in court. We cannot force them and their brother to withdraw the case. If they withdraw it today, to God be the glory," he said.
"We are still praying and we are not relenting. God Almighty is a miraculous God."

The court will reconvene on January 27, 2027, for ruling on the application.

0/Post a Comment/Comments

Peoplesmind Ads

Peoplesmind.com.ng