The Highest Calling

David Rubenstein’s The Highest Calling is a meticulously assembled collection of interviews with presidential historians and even a few real presidents—spanning from George Washington to Joe Biden. Rather than a sweeping narrative history, it reads as a tapestry of voices: scholars like Ron Chernow, Annette Gordon-Reed, Candice Millard, and presidents themselves reflecting on the pressures, ethics, and gravity of leading a nation.

Rubenstein’s background, as a White House staffer, founder of the Carlyle Group, and major philanthropic supporter of national landmarks, gives him rare access, lending the discussions a sense of immediacy and breadth. The result is less a traditional book and more a compendium of insights from some of the sharpest minds in American presidential study.

5 Standout Lessons from The Highest Calling:

1. Every President Is Remarkably Different—Yet Bound by Shared Burdens

Through 21 profiles, Rubenstein emphasizes the stark contrasts in presidents’ backgrounds, temperaments, and priorities—from Washington’s reluctant leadership to Biden’s lifetime dedication—but underscores the constant weight of the office.

2. Hypotheticals Shed Surprising Light

Rubenstein’s willingness to indulge historians’ "what ifs"—such as Ron Chernow's reflection on whether Grant could have prevented Lincoln's assassination—adds nuance, reminding readers that history is often contingent on fragile moments and choices.

3. Character Traits Are Telling—Or Yet Underrated

Explorations into presidents like Jimmy Carter reveal how strong virtues—dedication, integrity—can coexist with flaws like self-righteousness. Kai Bird’s comment that Carter’s honesty “helps to explain his political failings” illustrates the complexity of leadership.

4. Voter Participation Is the Cornerstone of Presidential Power

Rubenstein spotlights the tension between presidential authority and public mandate—citing turnout statistics, including a record-breaking 66.8% in 2020—arguing that the presidency truly matters only when supported by democratic engagement.

5. Proximity to Power Doesn’t Guarantee Insight

Having political connections—hosting Thanksgiving for Biden or attending Mar-a-Lago—gives access, but doesn’t produce the penetrating questions his subjects need. Critics argue that Rubenstein often sticks to surface-level queries rather than pressing the "why" behind presidency's impact .

If you’re a history enthusiast, a civics student, or someone interested in leadership through time, The Highest Calling provides a rich, multi-voiced snapshot of America’s most consequential office and the individuals who have worn its burden.